[For the Advertiser.]
INTERNATIONAL HOUSE, Feb. 13, 1862.
Mr. Editor;— As you have given me the privilege of answering an article in your paper of the 11th inst., where you classed me with spiritualists, mesmerizers, clairvoyants, &c., I take this occasion to state where I differ from all classes of doctors, from the Allopathic physician to the healing medium. All these admit disease as an independent enemy of mankind; but the mode of getting rid of it divides them in their practice.— The old school admit that medicines contain certain curative properties, and that certain medicines will produce certain effects. This is their honest belief. The Homoeopathic physicians believe their infinitessimals produce certain effects. This is also honest. But I believe all their medicine is of infinitely less importance than the opinions that accompany it. I never make war with medicine, but with opinions. I never try to convince a patient that trouble arises from calomel or any other poison. But the poison of the doctors' opinion in admitting a locating disease. But another class under cover of spiritualism and mesmerism, claim power from another world, and to these my remarks are addressed. I was one of the first mesmerizers in the State who gave public experiments, and had a subject who was considered the best then known, He examined and prescribed for diseases just as this class do now, and I know how much reliance can be placed on a medium, for when in this state they are governed by the superstitution and beliefs of the person they are in communication with, and read all their thoughts and feelings in regard to their disease, whether the patient is aware of them or not.
The capacity of thought-reading is the common extent of mesmerism. Clairvoyance is very rare and can be easily tested by blind-folding the subject and giving him a book to read. If he can read without seeing, that is conclusive evidence that he has independent sight. This was my test during my experiments. This state is of very short duration. They then come into that state where they are governed by surrounding minds. All the mediums of this day reason about medicine as much as the regular physicians.— They both believe in disease, and both recommend medicine. When I mesmerize my subject, he would prescribe some little simple herb that would do no harm or good of itself. In some cases this would cure the patient. I also found that any medicine would cure certain cases, if he ordered it. This led me to investigate the matter and arrive at the stand I now take; that the cure is not in the medicine, but in the confidence of the doctor or medium. A clairvoyant never reasons nor alters his opinion; but if in the first state of thought-reading, he prescribes medicine, he must be posted by some mind interested in it, and also must derive his knowledge from the same source as the doctors do. The subject I had, left me and was employed by John B. Dodds, who employed him in examining diseases in the mesmeric sleep, and taught him to recommend such medicines as he got up himself in Latin, and as the boy did not know Latin, it looked very mysterious. Soon afterwards he was at home again, and I put him asleep to examine a lady, expecting that he would go on in his old way, but instead of that he wrote a long prescription in Latin. I awoke him that he might read it, but he could not; so I took it to the Apothecary's, who said he had not the articles, and that they would cost twenty dollars.— This was impossible for the lady to pay, so I returned and put him asleep again, and he gave his usual prescription of some little herb, and she got well. This, with the fact that all these mediums admit disease, and derive their knowledge from the common allopathic belief, convinces me that if it were not for the superstition of the people, believing that these subjects, merely because they have their eyes shut, know more than the apothecaries; they could make few cures. Let any medium open his eyes, and let the patient describe his disease, then the medicine would do about as much good as brown bread pills. But let the eyes be shut and then comes the mystery. It is true that they will tell the feelings, but that is all the difference.
Now I deny disease as a truth, but admit it is a deception, stated like all other stories, without any foundation, and handed down from generation to generation, till the people believe it, and it has become a part of their lives, so they live a lie, and their senses are in it. To illustrate this, suppose I tell a person he has the diptheria, and he is perfectly ignorant of what I mean. So I describe the feelings and tell the danger of the disease, and how fatal it is in many places. This makes the person nervous, and I finally convince him of the disease. I have now made one, and he attaches himself to it, and really understands it, and he is in it soul and body. Now he goes to work to make it, and in a short time it makes its appearance. My way of curing convinces him that he has been deceived, and if I succeed the patient is cured. As it is necessary that he should feel that I know more than he does. I tell his feelings. This he cannot do to me, for I have no fears of diptheria. My mode is entirely original. I know what I say and they do not, if their word is to be taken. Just so long as this humbug of inventing diseases continues, just so long the people will be sick and be deceived by the above named crafts.
Feb. 14, 1862
P. P. Quimby
You can watch a video of this article below. (Full screen HD is available for high-speed Internet connections.)
Letter to the Editor was written by Phineas Parkhurst Quimby on February 13, 1862. Published on Feb. 14, 1862 in the Portland (Maine) Advertiser Newspaper and included in: Phineas Parkhurst Quimby: His Complete Writings and Beyond, by the Phineas Parkhurst Quimby Resource Center. Narration by Ronald A. Hughes. Running time 7:32
For where two or three are gathered together in my name, there am I in the midst of them. ~Matthew 18:20
Occasionally, Phineas Parkhurst Quimby would suggest that certain patients work together for the healing benefit of all involved. From his Portland office on December 7, 1861, we find him writing to “Miss Longfellow,” a childhood friend and neighbor, and in closing, he prescribes:
I will stop now, but remember that as long as you read this and drink in these words, you do it in remembrance of me, not P.P.Q., but Science, till your health comes. I will leave you now and come again and lead you till you can go alone. If you will see fit to show this to Julia H. when you read it, we shall all be together, and you know what the truth says: that when two or three are gathered together in Science, Truth or Wisdom will be there and bless and explain to them.
If you would like to have a free daily dose of Health and Happiness from Dr. Quimby delivered to your email inbox, please fill out the form below and then click on the "submit" button. Join us in our daily gathering. Your information will remain private.
Note: Even if you are already subscribed to our monthly newsletter, you will still need to sign-up to receive our daily quotations.
The Kindle version of Phineas Parkhurst Quimby: His Complete Writings and Beyond is now available through the Amazon web site here.
The most comprehensive Quimby publication that has ever been published, is now at the incredibly low price of $9.99! If you already have a Kindle account, you can click on this link — make your purchase — and be reading your very own copy of this book in 60 seconds or less!
Don't have a Kindle? Amazon has free reading apps for your Web Browser; iPhone; Windows PC; Mac; BlackBerry; iPad; Android; and Windows Phone 7. Visit the Amazon web site here for more information.
The "Comments and Reviews" page is here.
Live outside the United States? Contact us for international shipping rates at
If “a picture is worth a thousand words,” how many words would moving pictures be worth? I will leave that for you to decide.
A new section of free videos is now available to visitors of the Resource Center.
You can access the videos through the “video” tab that is located at the top of nearly every web page on the web site. Alternatively, just click this link: http://www.ppquimby.com/video/video1.htm to get started.
In Wisdom, Love and Light,
P.S. AOL and other subscribers to our newsletter might want to add our email address to their "white list" so your copy will reach you without delay or interruption. (email@example.com).
You may now keep in touch with us on Facebook at http://www.facebook.com/PPQuimby and follow us on Twitter: http://twitter.com/ppquimby. Our YouTube Channel is http://www.youtube.com/ppquimby and visit our Gift Shop on Zazzle here.
As a reminder, notification of our Science of Wisdom newsletter can be delivered to your email address each month at no charge. Just go to the Phineas Parkhurst Quimby Resource Center at http://www.ppquimby.com, and use the sign-up form that is found on nearly every page.